Welcome to our witchy episode of Novel Nights, where we, Francesca from Under the Covers Book Blog, Laura from What to Read Next, and Victoria from the BiblioLifestyle, dive into some of our favorite witchy reads you should add to your TBR this year!
This post contains affiliate links. That means we receive a small commission at no cost to you from any purchases you make through these links.
Novel Nights: Witchy Reads to Read in 2024
In the mood for some enchanting reads? Whether you’re after classic witch tales, cozy paranormal romances, or darker witchcraft stories, we’ve got you covered. This list of witchy reads will satisfy every type of magic lover, from Gothic atmospheres to modern, feel-good stories.
Victoria’s Witchy Reads Book Recommendations
Macbeth by William Shakespeare
An iconic tale of ambition and fate, Macbeth introduces the ominous Weird Sisters, whose prophecies set Macbeth on a destructive path to power. Full of supernatural influence and dark twists, this Shakespearean tragedy explores how ambition can lead to madness. A must-read for fans of classic literature with witchy, Gothic vibes.
The Crucible by Arthur Miller
Set during the Salem witch trials, The Crucible dives into the chaos of hysteria and fear as a group of girls accuses others of witchcraft. Neighbors turn against neighbors, and paranoia grips the entire town. It’s a powerful look at how fear can fuel societal breakdown—a great pick if you’re intrigued by the darker side of historical witch lore.
Wicked by Gregory Maguire
A reimagining of The Wizard of Oz, Wicked tells the story of the Wicked Witch of the West from her own perspective. Humanizing a villain, this novel challenges ideas of good and evil in a fantastical world. As the witch navigates love, identity, and power, her story takes on a depth that’ll make you question everything you thought you knew.
The Witching Tide by Margaret Meyer
Set in England, The Witching Tide centers on a mute midwife during a historical witch hunt. When her friend is accused of witchcraft, the protagonist confronts the dangerous power dynamics and paranoia of her society. With feminist themes and rich atmosphere, this literary novel offers a haunting, historical look at witch trials outside of Salem.
The Year of the Witching by Alexis Henderson
The Year of the Witching follows a young woman discovering her mother’s witchy past in a town where magic is feared. This dark fantasy explores themes of identity, rebellion, and power in an oppressive society. With its eerie atmosphere and feminist undertones, this is an ideal read for those who love horror blended with deep themes.
Best Hex Ever by Nadia El-Fassi
A charming contemporary romance featuring a kitchen witch cursed in love. The heroine’s magical cooking brings joy to her London café patrons, but her love life is a mess due to a pesky hex. When she meets a museum curator at a wedding, she wonders if breaking the curse is worth it. Light, funny, and heartwarming!
Laura’s Witchy Reads Book Recommendations
The Ex Hex by Erin Sterling
This cozy romcom follows a witch who curses her ex-boyfriend—only to find out it actually worked! As the ex returns to town, they must team up to break the curse while navigating lingering feelings. With fun fall vibes, second-chance romance, and magical mishaps, it’s perfect for readers craving a light, magical romcom.
Witches Get Stitches by Juliette Cross
In New Orleans, a tattoo artist witch who can imbue magic into her designs is stuck in a slow-burn romance with her werewolf best friend. As they work together on the tattoo shop, their relationship simmers with tension. Packed with small-town charm, found family, and paranormal fun, it’s a cozy pick for monster romance fans.
Check out our interview with Juliette Cross where she chats about the Stay a Spell series and shares her favorite paranormal romantic comedies.
Payback’s a Witch by Lana Harper
Three ex-girlfriends team up to take down a mutual ex in a competition that could change their magical community forever. With small-town vibes, a touch of revenge, and a cute lesbian romance, this book is Sabrina meets John Tucker Must Die in the best way. Perfect for those who love witty, witchy, queer romance.
What the Hex by Alexis Daria
Set in Miami, What the Hex follows a witch family, Kardashians-style, with a chaotic family curse threatening a major wedding. It’s a quick, beachy read full of drama, humor, and family dynamics. If you’re craving a shorter read with plenty of magic and Latinx vibes, this novella is just the thing.
The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna
A cozy, feel-good read about an orphaned witch who’s invited to train three young witches in a small town. She finally finds a sense of home, community, and maybe even romance. Perfect for readers looking for a lighthearted, magical read with themes of found family and self-discovery.
Francesca’s Witchy Reads Book Recommendations
Spookily Yours by Jennifer Chipman
In this paranormal romance, a witch with a café and her demon-in-a-cat hero are cursed enemies, but they’re also fated mates. When she accidentally adopts him (in cat form), sparks fly as they work together to break his curse. With Halloween vibes and cozy small-town charm, this one’s a cute, low-stakes read.
Heart of Darkness by Lauren Dane
A witch investigating a sexy underground club owner ends up working with him to uncover a plot threatening their magical community. With political intrigue, intense chemistry, and an urban fantasy setting, Heart of Darkness is perfect for readers who enjoy a mix of magic and romance with a suspenseful edge.
The Marionettes by Katie Wismer
In this Vampire Academy-meets-witches setup, the heroine joins an elite group of witches who serve vampire royalty. With deadly trials, academy dynamics, and a hint of romance with a vampire prince, this series starter offers everything fans of dark fantasy romance love: secrets, power struggles, and slow-burn tension.
Unholy Ghosts by Stacia Kane
In a dystopian world where ghosts are real, our heroine is a church debunker with a complicated past and an even messier life. Battling addiction and haunted by debts to a drug dealer, she faces her demons—literally. This gritty urban fantasy is raw and haunting, with an anti-heroine worth rooting for.
Dead Witch Walking by Kim Harrison
A witch bounty hunter on the run from her old job, Rachel Morgan teams up with a vampire and a pixie to survive a magical world full of enemies. It’s chaotic, funny, and full of urban fantasy action with a touch of romance. Rachel’s screw-ups make her journey relatable and fun, especially with her quirky sidekicks.
Resources and Guides
We also encourage everyone to download Victoria’s fall reading guide, packed with book recommendations, activities, and even a fun fall reading challenge. And you can also download the Under the Covers fall reading guide with 42 books categorized for your perfect spooky mood, plus a fall movie list and more.
Upcoming Live Shows
Stay tuned for our future live shows
We have an exciting calendar planned, and we can’t wait to chat with you every Thursday at 7 p.m. Eastern time.
Join the Conversation
That’s our roundup of must-read witchy books for this fall! From classic Shakespeare to cozy paranormal romcoms, there’s something magical here for every reader. Let us know in the comments which witchy read you’re adding to your TBR, and check out more of our fall book recommendations below. Happy reading!
Read more
- Witchy romantic comedies
- Gothic witch books
- Favorite witches of all time
- Witch romance books on Kindle Unlimited
- All our witchy book recommendations
- More Novel Nights replays
Pin it for later
Join the Under the Covers Community
- Book Release Calendar
- Book Tropes Book Database
- Reading Under the Covers: Extra Bite – Exclusive Bonus Podcast Feed
- Additional recommendation lists
- Reading wrap-ups and our Bookish Brunch weekly behind the scenes newsletter
- Free downloads (activities, templates and more)
- And much more!