‘Tis the season for… yet another stack of books to add to your ever-growing TBR! If your list is starting to resemble Santa’s scroll (endless and slightly intimidating), don’t worry—you’re definitely not alone. 2024 is bringing us a fun lineup of holiday paranormal romances, because what could be better than cozying up with a warm drink and reading about vampires celebrating the season or witches making holiday mischief? Seasonal vibes meet supernatural fun in these 15 books, ready to give your holidays that magical twist you’re craving.
Want even more holiday books? Check out our seasonal holiday reading hub.
This post contains affiliate links. That means we receive a small commission at no cost to you from any purchases you make through these links.
15 Fun 2024 Holiday Paranormal Romances
The Merriest Misters by Timothy Janovsky
Married less than a year, Patrick and Quinn’s romance faces struggles—until Patrick accidentally knocks out Santa. Now tasked with saving Christmas, they must become Santa Claus and the “Merriest Mister.” With their marriage and the holiday on the line, they’re in for a year of festive chaos, love, and second chances.
Grimm Curiosities by Sharon Lynn Fisher
In 1851, Lizzy Grimm inherits her late father’s eerie curiosity shop, only to discover its ghostly secrets. Partnering with Antony Carlisle to solve the mysterious affliction plaguing their loved ones, they delve into her father’s rare books on myths and enchantments. But unlocking these secrets could unleash a dark holiday danger.
Christmas Eve Love Story by Ginny Baird
Annie Jones is stuck in a time loop, reliving Christmas Eve repeatedly. As she keeps waking up to the same day, Annie teams up with security guard Braden to fix her holiday window display and navigate her new reality. With infinite chances, she starts finding love, friendship, and everything she’s been missing.
The Wedding Witch by Erin Sterling
Bowen Penhallow, a loner witch, and Tamsyn Bligh, a human who trades magical items, get transported back to 1958 after a Yuletide wedding spell goes awry. Stranded in the past, they must unravel the mystery of Tywyll House while facing their growing attraction—making for a delightfully witchy, time-traveling holiday romance.
Flopping In a Winter Wonderland by Jason June
Aaron and Kris both have their Christmas missions—Aaron wants his brother single, and Kris needs to win a love race to help his uncle. When they literally flop into each other, their plans align, but unexpected sparks fly. In this LGBTQ+ rom-com, true love may be the best surprise of all.
Want more queer holiday books? Check out our list of 2024 queer holiday romance books.
Don’t Kiss and Spell by Camilla Isley
Mila brews a love potion, but instead of a charming date, she gets Riley, the infuriating Chief Inquisitor who arrests her for murder. Cleared of charges but forced to work with him to solve a case, sparks fly. Can love from a potion be real, or is there more magic at play?
The Nightmare Before Kissmas by Sarah Raasch
Prince Coal Claus is tired of Christmas PR, and a hot make-out with Halloween’s Prince Hex seems like a good escape—until Coal’s ordered into a marriage of convenience with the Easter Princess. Now, it’s a fake competition, undeniable chemistry, and a chaotic, heartfelt holiday romance that’s delightfully unforgettable.
A Bloom in Winter by J.R. Ward
In this winter installment of the Black Dagger Brotherhood series, Callum, seeking purpose, joins the fight against the Lessening Society. Apex, determined to protect Callum, joins too. As they face danger together, they find unexpected love—but Callum must choose between opening his heart or succumbing to darkness.
Sanctuary by Ilona Andrews
Roman, a Volhv wizard serving Chernobog, wishes for a quiet holiday, but when a wounded boy arrives seeking sanctuary, chaos follows. Mercenaries, combat mages, and priests descend on Roman’s property, but they chose the wrong priest to mess with. It’s a battle for survival, but for Roman, it’s just another day.
Hex in the City by Josh Lanyon
Cosmo and John are ready for their first Christmas together—if they can survive nosy neighbors, difficult relatives, and a string of murders possibly linked to Krampus. In this holiday mystery, love, magic, and a touch of danger make for a festive, unpredictable ride.
This book is coming out December 1, 2024 and currently not available for pre-order
Mated for Christmas by Terry Spear
Arctic wolf shifters Sheri and Slade plan a cozy, romantic Christmas getaway in Minnesota, but unexpected trouble threatens their festive retreat. Together, they must face the danger if they want to savor their holiday romance. A heartwarming and thrilling holiday adventure for shifter romance fans.
The Knotty Clause by Honey Phillips
Single mom Gemma and her son find unexpected refuge with Yede, a gruff alien hiding in the mountains, after escaping a cruel mining boss. Though Yede wants privacy, Gemma finds herself wanting more. As holiday warmth melts Yede’s icy exterior, can they take a chance on love and create some holiday magic?
Dancer and the Ice Bear by Eve Langlais
Reindeer shifter Dancer must save Santa’s Village from Krampus, but ends up lost in a blizzard. She crash-lands at Nanook’s—a grumpy, holiday-hating polar bear. When Krampus kidnaps Nanook’s daughters, they team up for a daring rescue, and Dancer faces her toughest challenge yet: warming the ice bear’s heart.
A Witch for Mr. Garland by Deanna Chase
Sixteen years after their painful breakup, spirit witch Marissa seeks help from Danny, the seer who ran from their love. Danny, determined to make amends, still loves her, and as holiday magic fills Christmas Grove, their hearts find a chance to heal and rekindle what was lost.
The Witch’s Christmas Catastrophe by Kristen Painter
Witch Holly Winters just wanted a peaceful Christmas in Nocturne Falls, but dark magic has other plans. Teaming up with her brooding vampire neighbor Demetrius, they fight to save their supernatural town—and maybe find love amidst the snowstorms and magical chaos.
I hope you found some exciting new reads to add to your list this holiday season! Let me know in the comments which of these 2024 holiday paranormal romance books you’re planning to pick up, or if there are any others on your radar. And if you’re in the mood for even more holiday magic, check out the other festive romance blog posts below—there’s no such thing as too many holiday happily-ever-afters!
Read More
- 2024 Kindle Unlimited holiday romance books
- Most anticipated 2024 holiday romance books
- 2024 Spicy holiday romance books
- Queer 2024 holiday romance books
- 2022 Christmas romance book releases
Pin It for Later
Join the Under the Covers Community
- Book Release Calendar
- Book Tropes Book Database
- Reading Under the Covers: Extra Bite – Exclusive Bonus Podcast Feed
- Additional recommendation lists
- Reading wrap-ups and our Bookish Brunch weekly behind the scenes newsletter
- Free downloads (activities, templates and more)
- And much more!