This post contains affiliate links. That means we receive a small commission at no cost to you from any purchases you make through these links.
Looking for the best September and October 2024 Kindle Unlimited books? This month’s reading roundup has something for everyone, including some hidden gems. These are the books I personally read and loved on Kindle Unlimited this month, featuring both new releases and older titles. If you’re building your TBR, let this list inspire your next binge!
For even more KU books, check out all our Kindle Unlimited book recommendations and new releases here.
Best September and October 2024 Kindle Unlimited Books I Read and Recommend
There were so many amazing September and October 2024 Kindle Unlimited books we read that it would’ve been an incredibly long list. So here are the highlights!

Phantasma by Kaylie Smith
Ophelia enters Phantasma, a deadly game inside a haunted mansion, to save her sister. She must survive nine perilous trials while navigating demons, monsters, and fierce rivals. When a dangerous and alluring stranger offers a tempting deal, her life—and heart—hangs in the balance.
Check out even more ghost romance books!

The C*ck Down the Block by Amy Award
Best friends to fake dating with a twist: he’s a cocky quarterback, and she’s the curvy librarian he’s always secretly loved. Add her v-card revelation, and things get… complicated. This is a sweet, spicy story about second chances, self-worth, and an unlikely love that’s been years in the making.

Scream for Us by Molly Doyle
This novella is a dark, twisted ride perfect for fans of horror, mask kink, and why-choose romances. Quinn finds herself caught in a thrilling, dangerous game with three masked men at a Halloween party. Expect knife play, revenge, and a night of wild pleasure and violence that may never be forgotten.
If you’re looking for more spicy and scary books, check out our Spicy Booktok Halloween Book recs.

The Orc and the Innkeeper by Cora Crane
A fake relationship sets the stage in this sweet, small-town orc romance. The human innkeeper and the grumpy orc team up for a business deal that turns into much more. Expect plenty of steam, light humor, and a heartwarming romance that deals with prejudice and finding love in the most unexpected places.
Are you ready to explore some monsters? Check out our episode full of orc romance book recommendations.

Later On We’ll Conspire by Kortney Keisel
Holiday fling meets spy thriller! Lacee’s cozy Christmas plans unravel when her charming stranger turns out to have deadly secrets. Think Die Hard but with more chemistry, witty banter, and the ultimate question: can she trust him—or her own heart?

The Marionettes by Katie Wismer
Blood witch Valerie fights for her place in a dangerous league of witches serving vampires. Trials, betrayals, and secrets threaten her life—and her heart. A dark, twisty fantasy with enemies-to-lovers vibes and enough angst to keep you hooked.

Spookily Yours by Jennifer Chipman
A witch falls for her cursed, demon-turned-cat companion in this whimsical Halloween romance. Love between a human and a demon is impossible… right? Cozy, magical, and heartbreakingly sweet, with just the right amount of spice.

Power Play by Chelsea Curto
A divorced woman turns to an NHL goalie for lessons in the bedroom, but when their “casual” arrangement turns into a surprise Vegas wedding, things get messy. Friends-to-lovers, fake marriage, and a spicy teach-me trope make this one a total score.

Nocticadia by Keri Lake
Dark academia meets forbidden romance. A student haunted by her past, a professor known as “Doctor Death,” and a university dripping in gothic secrets. Their connection is intoxicating, but unearthing the truth could destroy them both. Twisted, atmospheric, and undeniably seductive.
This and more gothic books were featured in our Novel Nights gothic book recommendations episode.
Read More
- Looking for more Kindle Unlimited books? Check out our hub.
Pin It Later


Join the Under the Covers Community
- Book Release Calendar
- Book Tropes Book Database
- Reading Under the Covers: Extra Bite – Exclusive Bonus Podcast Feed
- Additional recommendation lists
- Reading wrap-ups and our Bookish Brunch weekly behind the scenes newsletter
- Free downloads (activities, templates and more)
- And much more!