10 Paranormal and Fantasy Cupid Books

This post contains affiliate links. That means we receive a small commission at no cost to you from any purchases you make through these links.

10 Irresistible Cupid Books Packed with Magic, Mischief & Romance

Cupid might be the god of love, but let’s be real—his arrows cause more trouble than romance. Whether it’s a mischievous matchmaker getting tangled in his own magic, a broody immortal meddling in human affairs, or a love-skeptic forced to play wingman, these paranormal and fantasy romances put a fresh spin on Cupid’s myth.

But before we get into the book recs, let’s talk about the winged troublemaker himself.

Is Cupid a Roman God?

Yes! Cupid comes from Roman mythology, but he’s based on Eros, the Greek god of love and desire. While modern depictions show him as a chubby cherub, the myths tell a different story. He was mischievous, powerful, and sometimes downright reckless with his arrows.

One of the most famous myths about him is Eros and Psyche, a love story filled with trials, betrayals, and divine intervention. If you love mythology-inspired romance, check out our list of Eros and Psyche book recommendations for retellings that bring their epic love story to life.

But Cupid’s influence isn’t just in ancient myths—his magic lives on in paranormal and fantasy romances. These books take the concept of love and arrows to a whole new level, with cupids getting caught in their own spells, gods running dating apps, and matchmakers falling for the wrong person.

10 Paranormal and Fantasy Romance Cupid Books

Signs of Cupidity by Raven Kennedy

Signs of Cupidity by Raven Kennedy

Being a cupid sucks when you can’t get any love for yourself. After an exile to the fae world and a misfired Love Arrow, a bitter cupid finds herself suddenly very human—and very interested in the fae princes now paying attention to her. A slow-burn, why-choose romance with a mischievous cupid in over her head.

Grab this book on Amazon

Related post: Escape reality with these 9 fantasy romcom books

Hit by the Cupid Stick by Abigail Owen

Hit by the Cupid Stick by Abigail Owen

A flirtatious cupid with a matchmaking streak accidentally shoots himself and falls for a siren who lures men to their deaths. He’s all charm, she’s all cynicism—except now he’s obsessed with her. But cupid magic is temporary… right? A fun, enemies-to-lovers, forced proximity romance with a dash of danger.

Grab this collection on Amazon

Petty Cupid by Sarah Blue

Petty Cupid by Sarah Blue

A cupid desperate for a fake date to make her ex jealous ends up with the grim reaper as her plus-one. What starts as a petty revenge plan turns into something much deeper. Death and love don’t mix… or do they? Opposites attract in this Valentine’s Day romance.

Grab this book on Amazon

Book cover Crazy Cupid Love by Amanda Heger

Crazy Cupid Love by Amanda Heger

She’s a reluctant cupid with zero belief in true love. He’s her childhood crush turned mentor. When a matchmaking gig goes wrong, they’re stuck untangling a magical mess that could destroy love itself. Forced proximity, slow-burn tension, and an unlikely second chance at romance.

Grab this book on Amazon

Dating Cupid by Eve Langlais

Dating Cupid by Eve Langlais

She’s done with love and ready to take down the company that sells it—Cupid’s Dating Service. Too bad its CEO is literally Cupid himself, and he’s ridiculously attractive. Sparks fly between a love cynic and the god of love in this steamy, enemies-to-lovers romance.

Grab this book on Amazon

Love & Curse Making by Kelly St. Claire

Love & Curse Making by Kelly St. Clare

Running a paranormal dating agency would be great if she weren’t cursed to never find love herself. When her magic flares up in front of a broody detective, she’s suddenly under investigation—and caught in a mystery tied to her own powers. A snarky, slow-burn romance with a supernatural twist.

Grab this book on Amazon

Sweet Girl by Jack Whitney

Sweet Girl by Jack Whitney

He’s not a cherub with a bow and arrow—he’s a modern-day Cupid running a dating app. Valentine’s is his busiest night, but a chance encounter with a no-nonsense woman at his singles event throws him off his game. A spicy, one-night romance with fate working overtime.

Grab this book on Amazon

I'm with Cupid by Sarah Spade

I’m with Cupid by Sarah Spade

Being a cupid means making love matches, not being in them. But when he accidentally pricks himself with his own arrow, he loses his wings—and might have just found the one woman who can help him get them back. A road trip romance with forced proximity and a touch of magic.

Grab this book on Amazon

Stupid Cupid by Maeve Black

Stupid Cupid by Maeve Black

He’s been burned before and doesn’t believe in love. He’s also a cupid. When a bossy, dominant stranger crashes into his world, suddenly love doesn’t seem so impossible. A grumpy cupid meets his match in this M/M romance with plenty of tension.

Grab this book on Amazon

Can't Fix Cupid by Raven Kennedy

Can’t Fix Cupid by Raven Kennedy

Cupid with broken arrows vs. billionaire allergic to love. Grumpy sunshine with “I can fix him” vibes. Magic mishaps, steamy bets, and a HEA that’ll make you side-eye every bird with a bow. PSA: Billionaires do melt for adorkable disaster cupids.

Grab this book on Amazon

More Valentine’s Day Romance Reads

Looking for more romance that screams February 14th? If you want something beyond these cupid books to celebrate love this season, we’ve got you covered. Check out this list of Valentine’s Day-themed romances featuring everything from cozy to spicy love stories set against the backdrop of Valentine’s chaos.

Cupid might be all about love, but these books prove that romance is never that simple. Which one of these romance books about cupid are you picking up first? Let me know in the comments! And if you’ve read any that you loved, share them in the comments.

Read more:

Pin it for later

10 Paranormal and Fantasy Romance Books About Cupid

Join the Under the Covers Community

  • Book Release Calendar
  • Book Tropes Book Database
  • Reading Under the Covers: Extra Bite – Exclusive Bonus Podcast Feed
  • Additional recommendation lists
  • Reading wrap-ups and our Bookish Brunch weekly behind the scenes newsletter
  • Free downloads (activities, templates and more)
  • And much more!

Join our bookish community →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

2 Comments