Bookshelf Organization Ideas and What Actually Worked for Me

It’s confession time…I have reorganized my bookshelves more time and more ways than I can count.
Different homes. Different shelves. Different reading eras. Different times when I thought, surely, the TBR will become manageable.

Spoiler alert: the TBR remains undefeated.

I’ve been collecting books for over a decade now, moved and changed shelves, tried practical systems, pretty systems, and yes, I’ve occasionally bought a duplicate or two because my memory is not reliable. Along the way I’ve learned what works for me and that is the best bookshelf organization system is the one that matches you current mood and reading life.

Definitely not what Instagram says your shelves should look like. Not how the library does it. Not how your most organized friend does it (I’ve been that friend, I know).

Your system.

As romance readers, our systems have to account for a lot: subgeners, favorite authors, unfinished series, comfort re-reads, special editions, signed copies, your TBR. So today I’m walking through the bookshelf organization ideas I’ve actually tried over the years and telling you what worked, what looked beautiful but made no sense, and what I’m doing now with my current shelves.

This post contains affiliate links. That means we receive a small commission at no cost to you from any purchases you make through these links.

My Bookshelf Organization Has Changed With Every Home

Before we get to the tips, let me be clear: there isn’t just one perfect way to organize bookshelves. I’ve had several eras myself, and they each worked for different reasons at the time. At one point, I had dark wood bookshelves organized very sensibly alphabetically by authors’ last name. It was probably the most practical system I’ve ever had, especially for a large romance collection with a lot of authors, subgenres, and long-running series.

Then I had added a DIY crate bookshelf, where I grouped books by author. That worked well because I just had my favorite authors there and I could go straight to a little author zone when I wanted Nalini Singh, Lisa Kleypas, J.R. Ward, Ilona Andrews. It was cute and visually one of my favorites, but eventually when you have a lot of books, that definitely doesn’t give you a lot of space.

Then came the white built-ins, and I thought I had designed my dream bookshelf (spoiler: it wasn’t). But they were probably my most peaceful bookshelf era. I decided to do the Bookstagram thing I’ve seen people do and turned the books pages-out. Visually? Stunning. Calm. Minimal. The room felt instantly less noisy, especially because those shelves were behind my desk and I looked at them every day. Functionally, though? I couldn’t find a book to save my life. It was the kind of bookshelf system that looked like a dream and operated like a tiny personal nightmare if I needed one specific paperback.

Now my current shelves are grouped by genre, with no strict organization within each section which allows me to add things as I please when I get new books. It is not the most perfect system on paper, but it works for the way I browse now. Sometimes I want paranormal romance. Sometimes I want romantasy. Sometimes I want contemporary romance. I have a space on my shelf for ARCs and TBR. And that’s the real lesson: your bookshelf organization has to support your actual reading life, not just look pretty in a photo.

Start by Taking Everything Off the Shelves

When you start you are full of energy and you want to get everything off the shelves. This is also the best time to start making piles based on how you want to organize them (some ideas further down) and a great time to do some cleanup. The last time I organized my bookshelf, I unhauled 72 books!

Watch the process here:

When I reorganize, I usually sort books into loose piles first. If I’m doing alphabetically, then everything goes in piles by author. If I plan to keep the specials or favorites separate, then those get put aside too. That way when we are putting things back, the piles are easy to grab.

This stage is messy, and it’s also where overwhelm kicks in when you’re halfway if you have a large collection. By the way, this is also a great time to catalog your collection. I personally love to have a digital inventory of all the physical books I own because it helps me not buy duplicates anymore. When you’re putting in piles is exactly the time you want to be doing that work.

Organizing Books by Author

This was always the most straight-forward, and most effective system. I grouped books by author, alphabetically. It was perfect for my brain, I knew exactly what section of the bookshelf to go to without having to think of anything else (no genre, no series).

This is especially helpful if you are a series reader. Obviously keeping books but the same author helps you find a book in a series you’re reading, but also helps you to easily know what you own by that author (so you are not buying duplicates).

If you collect different covers, signed covers, special editions, etc, this will be your best friend.
The downside is that author grouping can get messy if your collection grows unevenly. You may organize thinking you only have 1 or 2 by that author and a year later find yourself buying 5 and now you don’t have the real estate on that shelf and need to reorganize. And depending where in the shelf system and how much it needs to shift, you may be looking at a whole bookshelf organization again.

Want the full shelf tour? I filmed a complete bookshelf tour of my old bookshelves many years ago, where everything was alphabetized by author. It is quite a bit long but you get to see my bookshelves at the time (and my whole book collection in 2016).

Organizing Books by Genre, Then Alphabetically by Author

My co-blogger at the time, Annie, did alphabetical bookshelves a little bit different. Her bookshelves were organized by genre first and then alphabetically by author’s last name. Every romance subgenre had its section of the bookshelf.

This is the perfect system if you are a mood reader. Feel like reading a vampire romance? You go exactly to the paranormal romance area and browse what you have.

The downside is again the maintenance. As you library gets bigger, you have to make sure you gave yourself enough space the first time you organized the books so you have some room to move things around without having to take everything off again too soon.

Organizing Books Pages-Out for Aesthetic and Calm

Now we need to talk about my most beautiful (in my opinion) and least practical system: the pages-out shelves.
When we had the white built-ins, I turned all the books around so the pages faced out like I saw on Bookstagram. And I know this is controversial. Some readers hate it. Some readers love it. And you may be wondering, “how do you find anything?”

The answer is: you do not. But I will defend the vibe.

Visually, those shelves were so peaceful to look at. They made the room feel calm and soft and reduced the visual clutter. I had these in my office and I was looking at them all day so I definitely needed that at the time.
This is perfect if you want your shelves to be a decorative piece in the room, you don’t go grab books too often, or if you’re putting them in a room where the visual clutter matters more than your speed to find books.

But for an active reader with a large collection? It turns every book search into a mystery. I hardly ever found anything.

If you still want to go for this, I will suggest making a very good “map” or system for where you are placing things, and definitely have an inventory of your collection digitally (you could even add notes to that inventory tracker in which exact “shelf” the book is, like a real library!). I have a step by step tutorial on how I use Libib as my book inventory software. No scanner required.

Organizing Books by Genre Only

My current shelves are grouped by genre, and within those genres… honestly, vibes.

No strict alphabetical order. No perfect series grid. Every book doesn’t have to live in a precise location. It’s the most freeing and surprisingly? This works for how I read right now.

Grouping by genre gives me enough structure to browse or add without turning my shelves into more work. I may even fudge the rules a little bit when I need to make space work. Is it the most efficient system if I need one specific book? No. Sometimes I do spend a few minutes looking for something. Would a librarian judge me? Possibly.

But it fits my current reading life, my space and the books I have in my house (majority of my books are in storage now), and that matters more than having a system that looks impressive but annoys me every time I use it.

Use a Small Display Shelf for Specific Books

Not every book has to live in your main organization system. I mean, for a while I had a lot of books living on the floor, you make have a stack by your nightstand. But a smaller display shelf can be useful. I like using smaller shelves for books that are by my favorite authors, or deserve some kind of special treatment.

This doesn’t have to be your entire collection. It can include: current TBR, seasonal reads, recent book mail you haven’t inventoried, comfort rereads, your Romanceopoly picks (if you’re doing our reading challenge), just to name a few.

The key is to treat display shelves as rotating space, not permanent storage. I’ve used an actual pretty shelf, DIY crate shelves, and even a “TBR cart” for this.

Organizing Books by Series

If you are a romance or fantasy reader, you especially need to keep your series in order. I used to do that within the author organization. But depending for you, maybe leading with a series organization may work better if that clicks more with your brain.

No matter what your start with (author, genre) series need to stay together. If your collection is series heavy, I recommend keeping each series together even if it slightly disrupts your bigger organization system.

Organizing Books by Read and Unread

For some readers, having a dedicated unread shelf is motivating and for others it’s the most stressful. I understand both.

A separate unread section can be helpful if you want to remember what you own and shop your own shelves more often. It can also help you avoid buying more books in a genre when you already have twelve unread ones.

But if seeing all your unread books together makes you feel guilty, skip it. Reading is not supposed to feel like a performance review. Try maybe a small priority TBR shelf instead. That way you can get some of that motivation without the constant guilt. Unless guilt works for you!

Organizing Books by Color

You’ve seen these all over social media. Beautiful rainbow shelves that look like a work of art, really. A full wall that’s arranged by color looks gorgeous in photos. That said, this is one method I never tried and I probably never will. I already know it would make me anxious. All the genres mixed, authors mixed, series mixed, and I have to visually look at it and see that one book has nothing to do with the one next to it. That would drive me bonkers. At least with the pages out, there was no organization, but I didn’t have to look at the chaos.

In order for you to find something if you use this system you need other have good memory for what each cover looks like. Or maybe just give more importance to the beautiful aesthetic that it gives to the room. In my opinion they are definitely more decor than a working system (like the pages out).

Use Decor Without Blocking the Books

I love bookish decor. Candles, crystals, figurines, mugs, flowers, bookends, little signs, fandom things that make absolutely no sense to anyone else but make you happy. Yes, use all of that. I also added at times picture frames with my photos with the authors by their books. Put all of that on the shelves. Your bookshelf does not have to look like a catalog. It should look like a reader lives there.

But the trick is making sure the decor does not get in the way of the books you actually reach for. I like decor in empty spaces, on top of horizontal stacks. It serves the purpose of saving space for growth of the collection. What I do not like is having to move five tiny objects every time I want a paperback. Keep that in mind!

Make Space for Book Overflow

As organized as you are, there will always be overflow. Yes, books end up on nightstands, desks, coffee tables etc. And when your collection grows, your system should have space to accommodate that without making you reorganize everything every quarter.

So when you reorganize your bookshelves this time, leave space for new additions. I personally like to use decor to buy some of that space. You can always put the decor somewhere else but it saves you the space where you know there’s a chance it’ll expand soon.

And make sure you have some designates spaces for new arrivals, a library book basket, a dedicate unhaul box, and like I mentioned before, maybe a small priority TBR shelf.

Maintain Your Bookshelves Without Making It a Whole Personality

Once your shelves are organized, I don’t think you need to constantly redo them. Unless you enjoy that. I mean, that’s a separate hobby in and of itself.

How often should you touch them? My rule of thumb is a refresh once a quarter. This is a great time to dust off the shelves, pull any books you no longer want to donate or sell, update your priority TBR shelf, if you use a cart, give that a refresh too, fix anything that was misplaced. No need for big overhauls all the time, although you could do that once a year if you’ve increased your collection quite a bit.

I’m not saying your bookshelf needs to be minimalist. Some of us are maximalists. But every shelf benefits from a refresh once in a while.

Another thing that makes keeping your shelves organized and finding what you have and what you need to read, is to keep a digital inventory of your physical (and digital) collection. Think of it like your personal catalog or library that you can just logon and search for a book before you even step to the bookshelf.

Your Bookshelves Should Work for Your Reading Life

After trying a lot of different bookshelf organization systems over the years, I don’t think there is one right way. Sometimes you need practical and sometimes you need pretty. It depends on the season of life, your taste, the people that live with you, the actual space. So many factors. 

For me right now, I need super low maintenance and I’ve made peace with that. I’m not full chaos gremlin but I have enough of a system to find things relatively quickly. 

How about you? How do you organize your bookshelf? Did I miss anything on this list? Leave me a comment and let’s chat about it.

Pin It for Later