These Books About Paranormal Creatures May Cause Book Hangovers and Feral Screaming
Craving books about paranormal creatures? This fall-ready list matches your favorite popular reads with fresh recs featuring vampires, werewolves, witches, and more. Perfect for fans of supernatural romance and fantasy
What to Read If You Like Paranormal Creatures: Fall Edition
Fall is peak paranormal reading season. The vibes? Immaculate. The book hangovers? Absolutely unavoidable. Whether you’re a vampire fangirl, a shifter simp, or just here for the magic, this list pairs big-name bangers with underrated picks so you can keep the supernatural binge going. Cozy up with these Fall books about paranormal creatures, charge your Kindle, and prepare for some feral screaming.
Prefer to listen instead?
This post contains affiliate links. That means we receive a small commission at no cost to you from any purchases you make through these links.
Your Fall Reading is Stacked with these Books About Paranormal Creatures
Whether you’ve read the popular books on this list or not, you’ll find lots of series to dig into. Pick up one, or both choices.
If You Love Bride by Ali Hazelwood, Read The Fake Mate by Lana Ferguson
Bride is a slow-burn, political alliance romance with a vampire heroine and a werewolf alpha forced into an arranged marriage. Their chemistry is off the charts, and the tension builds as they navigate their complicated feelings. With supernatural politics and sizzling slow-burn romance, this is perfect if you love complex characters and a bit of drama.
The Fake Mate features a fake relationship between two paranormal creatures. The enemies-to-lovers trope shines through as their “fake” arrangement slowly becomes all too real. With plenty of banter, steamy moments, and high-stakes supernatural politics, this shifter romance is perfect for readers who enjoy a lighter, more playful take on paranormal romance.
If you still can’t scratch that itch, I’ve got more books like Bride by Ali Hazelwood here.
If you love the Stay a Spell series by Juliette Cross then you’ll like the Haven Ever After series by Hazel Mack
In Wolf Gone Wild, you get an irresistible blend of witches, werewolves, and humor. When a werewolf hero struggles to control his wolf, a feisty witch steps in to help. The result is a hilarious and spicy romance with a strong sense of community and found family. Perfect for fans of fun paranormal rom-coms.
Getting It On with the Gargoyle is a quirky paranormal rom-com set in a magical small town. A grumpy gargoyle and a sunny heroine are thrown together, and sparks fly. With its mix of humor, steamy moments, and supernatural politics, this one’s ideal if you love the cozy, witchy charm of Wolf Gone Wild.
Grab Getting It On with Gargoyles on Amazon
You can also check out Juliette Cross’ favorite paranormal romantic comedy recommendations.
If you love the Black Dagger Brotherhood series by J.R. Ward then you’ll like the Dark Protectors series by Rebecca Zanetti
Black Dagger Brotherhood is a long-running series featuring alpha male vampires who fight to protect their species from soulless enemies. Each book focuses on one warrior’s intense romance while exploring themes of loyalty, brotherhood, and sacrifice. It’s full of brooding heroes, high-stakes action, and a strong found-family dynamic.
Would you like to save this?
Enter your email below, and we’ll send this post straight to your inbox. Plus, you'll join fellow readers and receive my book recommendations each week!
Dark Protectors is an intense, action-packed vampire series featuring alpha male heroes and strong supernatural battles. The story weaves together sizzling romance, fierce loyalty, and a world at war with an evil vampire race. Fans of Black Dagger Brotherhood will love this gripping, high-stakes series filled with protective heroes and fierce heroines.
And for even more books like Black Dagger Brotherhood, we’ve got you covered.
If you love From Blood and Ash by Jennifer L. Armentrout then you’ll like A Fate of Wrath and Flame by K.A. Tucker
From Blood and Ash is a fantasy romance that introduces us to Poppy, a heroine burdened with her destiny as the “Maiden.” Her forbidden romance with Hawke, a guard with a hidden agenda, sparks a series of revelations about their world. With political intrigue, action-packed scenes, and enemies-to-lovers tension, this book is a must for fans of epic romantasy.
Grab From Blood and Ash on Amazon
A Fate of Wrath and Flame features a modern-day thief, Romeria, who’s pulled into a magical kingdom full of royal betrayals and elemental magic. Posing as a princess, she must navigate her enemies-to-lovers relationship with King Zander, all while uncovering dark secrets. It’s perfect for readers who love immersive world-building and slow-burn fantasy romance.
Grab A Fate of Wrath and Flame on Amazon
If you love the Kate Daniels series by Ilona Andrews then you’ll like the Soulbound series by Hailey Turner
Kate Daniels is an urban fantasy series set in a post-apocalyptic Atlanta, where magic and technology collide. Kate, a tough mercenary with hidden powers, faces off against powerful supernatural forces while falling for the alpha of the shapeshifter pack, Curran. If you’re into slow-burn romance, witty banter, and action-packed plots, this series is a must-read.
The Soulbound series by Hailey Turner delivers a gritty urban fantasy with a strong LGBTQ+ romance. Following Patrick, a PTSD-suffering mage, and Jono, a werewolf god pack alpha, the series blends magic, gods, and plenty of action. If you love slow-burn romances with mythological creatures and high-stakes paranormal politics, this one’s for you.
Grab A Ferry of Bones and Gold on Amazon
And for even more badass urban fantasy, check out all our favorite books like Kate Daniels.
Bonus Creature Pairings:
Love morally grey vampires? Try King of Battle and Blood by Scarlett St. Clair
Obsessed with witchy girl gangs? Try Payback’s a Witch by Lana Harper
Need monster romance with actual claws? Try That Time I Got Drunk and Saved a Demon by Kimberly Lemming
Whether you’re here for the brooding vampires, cursed gargoyles, or flirty witches, these books about paranormal creatures are built to feed your fall obsession. Save this list, send it to your group chat, and prepare for your next reading spiral. You’re welcome.
Need more? Check out all our favorite fall books to keep your TBR stacked this season.
Pin It for Later
WANT MORE BOOK RECS?
Access our Book Vault Database
When you join the Under the Covers Community you’ll get access to our release calendar and trope database where you can see every book listed on the blog in a searchable and filterable database. Guaranteed to help you find your next read!
