3 Kindle Unlimited Underrated Paranormal Romance Books (You Probably Missed)

If you’re on Kindle Unlimited and feeling like you’ve already seen all the hyped paranormal romances… I got you. These three books flew under the radar but fully delivered. Think witchy curses, end-of-the-world angst, and a supervillain trying to rebrand with help from a shy PR girl.

They’re a little offbeat, a little unexpected, and 100% worth adding to your TBR. These Kindle Unlimited underrated paranormal romance books will surprise you in the best way.

This post contains affiliate links. That means we receive a small commission at no cost to you from any purchases you make through these links.

A Spell for Heartsickness by Alistair Reeves

Let’s start with a cursed witch and a murdered poltergeist roommate. Yes, really.

This is an MM witchy romance where the vibes are cozy-but-haunted, the main character is a magical fashion designer, and the town is giving cursed forest energy. Briar is literally dying from the same wasting curse that killed his mother, and he ends up in this tiny, eerie town thanks to a prophecy, with two potential love interests, both mysterious in very different ways.

The writing is quietly funny, deeply emotional, and absolutely magical. If you’re into witch romance books, this is the kind of gem KU was made for.

Imagine if a Studio Ghibli movie had a love triangle, a sarcastic magpie familiar, and a heavy dose of millennial existential dread.

Read A Spell for Heartsickness on Amazon

If you want even more witches, check out our full list of witch romance books on Kindle Unlimited.

Heart of the Sun by Mia Sheridan

Not your typical paranormal, but hear me out. This is dystopian second-chance romance with speculative elements that fully belong on this list.

It starts grounded — Emily’s a famous pop star, Tuck’s her childhood best friend turned ex-con. He becomes her bodyguard. Tension? Off the charts. But then a massive solar flare wipes out the power grid, and they’re suddenly navigating a collapsing society together.

The post-apocalyptic setting adds a whole new level of emotional intensity. This is for you if you like your romance with angst, grit, and second chances in the dark.

Think The Last of Us meets popstar bodyguard romance, but make it slow burn.

Read Heart of the Sun on Amazon

For even more end of the world drama, check out these dystopian romance books.

All Superheroes Need PR by Elizabeth Stephens

Okay this one is just fun. But make no mistake, it still hits the paranormal romance lane with a superhero twist.

Roland is a former villain trying to go full redemption arc. Vanessa is the PR director hired to rebrand him. Cue: fake dating, marketing chaos, sexual tension, and emotional vulnerability hiding under super-strength and sarcasm.

This one’s perfect for fans of superhero romance, enemies-to-lovers and characters who banter like it’s foreplay.

It’s giving The Boys but softer. With spandex. And feelings.

Read All Superheroes Need PR on Amazon

FAQ: Kindle Unlimited Underrated Paranormal Romance

Final Thoughts

If your KU library is starting to feel predictable, these Kindle Unlimited underrated paranormal romance books are here to shake things up. Each one blends genres in a way that feels fresh, with just enough magic, mayhem, or mutant energy to satisfy that supernatural itch.

Want more? Check out these other posts:

• Best Paranormal Romance Books on Kindle Unlimited
• Cozy Fantasy Romance for KU Readers
• Witch Romance Books on Kindle Unlimited
• Fae Romance Books on Kindle Unlimited
• 11 Paranormal Romance Books on Kindle Unlimited

Pin It for Later