13 Unforgettable Paranormal Cowboy Romances You Didn’t Know You Needed
When you think of cowboys, dusty trails and sunset skies probably come to mind. But these paranormal cowboy romances blend western grit with supernatural thrills—wolf shifters, vampire ranchers, alien wranglers, and post‑apocalyptic lawmen. Whether you’re new to the subgenre or a die‑hard fan, this list of non‑contemporary cowboy romances will surprise you.
For more on the roots of cowboy romance, check out my deep dive into “What Is Cowboy Romance?” and explore the most popular cowboy romance tropes.
Prefer to watch instead?
This post contains affiliate links. That means we receive a small commission at no cost to you from any purchases you make through these links.
Why We Love Paranormal Cowboy Romances
These mash‑ups let us escape to worlds where pack rules, cursed lands, and off‑world ranches meet classic cowboy tropes—grumpy heroes, fated mates, and high‑stakes rescues. They’re perfect for readers who want to stretch their imaginations beyond the usual dusty barn.
13 Must‑Read Paranormal Cowboy Romances
Rough by Renee Rose and Vanessa Vale
A rodeo‑champ wolf shifter breaks pack rules when he heals a human doctor in hours. Now he’s glued to her side—and ready to chase off any human man in his way in this grumpy/sunshine, enemies‑to‑lovers ride.
Caleb by Sarah McCarty
Allie’s beast attack rescue reveals rancher Caleb is a vampire shapeshifter. He must guard her from a rival pack and risk it all in this slow‑burn fated mates romance.
Dead Sexy by Kimberly Raye
Nikki’s casual dating life collides with vampire cowboy Jake. When she’s abducted, Jake must choose between saving her or keeping his last shot at humanity alive.
Cowboy Wolf Trouble by Kait Ballenger
Former renegade Wes Calhoun keeps his wolf pack at peace—until Naomi Evans uncovers their secret world. Sparks fly as clan war looms in this gruff/protective romance.
Grab Cowboy Wolf Trouble on Amazon
Married to an Alien Cowboy by Ursa Dax
On the run from a crime lord, a human woman marries stoic alien cowboy Silar under a thirty‑day trial. His glowing eyes and awkward charm upend her plan—and her heart.
Grab Married to the Alien Cowboy on Amazon
Cowboy from the Future by Cassandra Gannon
Adeline’s glamping trip catapults her 1,600 years ahead to a post‑apocalyptic West ruled by laser beasts. Grumpy cowboy Cade must escort her home, but their sparks ignite in this time‑travel romance.
Grab Cowboy from the Future on Amazon
Night of Fire by Nico Rosso
Ranger Tom Knox returns on an ether‑powered mechanical horse to help Sheriff Rosa Campos fend off a monstrous mining machine. Old flames flare amid steampunk suspense.
Death Valley by Karina Halle
Guide Jensen McGraw leads Aubrey Wells through Sierra Nevada’s zombie‑infested wilderness. As undead threats rise, so does their forbidden attraction in this dark horror Western.
High Moon by Kati Wilde
Makena Laine helps brooding rancher Ethan Grimmson—only to discover he’s a werewolf hunting his family’s killers. Under a high moon, they forge a fierce fated mates bond.
The Witch and the Cowboy by Ryen Rowe
Teen cowboy Walker Reid gets tangled in a witch’s murder investigation. Forced to clear his name, they face curses and forbidden attraction in a magical enemies‑to‑lovers showdown.
Grab The Witch and the Cowboy on Amazon
The Good, the Bad and the Vampire by Sara Humphreys
Vampire cowboy Dakota Shelton courts punk‑rocker Trixie LaRoux with cinnamon lollipops and Johnny Cash. When undead threats arise, chivalry—and love—prevails.
Grab The Good, the Bad, and the Vampire on Amazon
Song of Oestend by Marie Sexton
Bookkeeper Aren Montrell uncovers deadly wraiths on the Oestend prairie and befriends foreman Deacon. Secrets and heritage collide in this tense paranormal Western.
Grab Song of Oestend on Amazon
Wrangling the Orc Cowboy by Ava Ross
Reality‑TV escapee Gracie lands at Lonesome Creek’s orc attraction and clashes with cinnamon‑roll orc Tark. Their fated mates bond blends quirky wooing and spicy heat.
Grab Wrangling the Orc Cowboy on Amazon
Final Thoughts
These paranormal cowboy romances prove cowboys aren’t just human. From alien grooms to wolf‑shifting rodeo champs, each ride brims with fresh heat and heart. Which one will you saddle up with first? Let me know in the comments!
Read More
Pin It for Later
Join the Under the Covers Community
- Book Release Calendar
- Book Tropes Book Database
- Reading Under the Covers: Extra Bite – Exclusive Bonus Podcast Feed
- Additional recommendation lists
- Reading wrap-ups and our Bookish Brunch weekly behind the scenes newsletter
- Free downloads (activities, templates and more)
- And much more!