Dukes vs Pirates

Today on Under the Covers we are confronting that ever present conflict: Dukes vs Pirates. It’s a question that’s always churning in the back of our minds, what do we prefer? Would we like to be swept off our feet by a rich, charming and handsome aristocrat who comes with a grand house in London and a palatial estate in the country? Or would we trade it all in for life on the high seas with darkly handsome and wicked pirate, who would wine and dine us with a menu of cheap rum and exciting hi-jinks? How’s a body to choose? I certainly have trouble, some days luxuriating with my dashing duke on silky sheets being fed grapes sounds like heaven, other days I want to be captured by my swashbuckling and dangerously gorgeous pirate.

But, to help order my thoughts and perhaps finally make a choice I’ve split it down into three categories so that I can make a more in depth and informed decision regarding Dukes vs Pirates. I’m breaking it down to:

  • Fighting Prowess – Who would win a fight (over me!)?
  • Lifestyle – Who would keep me in the lifestyle to which I accustomed?
  • Physical Characteristics – Who has the best…form?

As a Ladies, we have our honour to consider as such, we need to ensure that our hero has the ability to defend said honour. As this is the case, in the decision between Dukes and Pirates careful consideration needs to be given to their fighting prowess, how good they are with some fisticuffs, a pistol and maybe even a sword. In this category I figured that the pirates would win hands down, however, I underestimated the skills of a duke.

First, their is Temple, known as the “Killer Duke”  from Sarah Macleans No Good Duke Goes Unpunishedbig, brawny and handy with his massive fists, he would give a hardened pirate pause for thought. Or maybe not. Not if you’re Fain Hauk from Sherrilyn Kenyon’s Born of Betrayal an instalment in her League series. Hauk is big and bad with a pair of fangs, that’s right not only is he a space pirate, he’s a space vampire as well. I think even Temple would have a bit of trouble with him! Then again, perhaps Gran Duke Alexander from The Mad, Bad Duke by Jennifer Ashley could have a go, he’s got a bit of the beast in him as well.

Of course, it’s much more bad ass when the a Lady can defend herself against all these ruffians…

Dukes and Pirates most likely to win in a duel:

A girl’s lifestyle is important and if she’s going to live some in a place and time that has either no indoor plumbing or it has only just been invented, then I think she deserves certain compensations. Like the ability to drape oneself in diamonds, or have the finest silk stockings. Or, have a big old chest filled with some pirate booty. In this category, I think that Dukes have the edge. Lets take Hart Mackenzie, Duke of Kilmorgan from Jennifer Ashley’s The Duke’s Perfect Wife. He’s dripping in wealth (and sexiness) and not only can he provide his Lady with silk sheets, he knows exactly what to do with his Lady on those silk sheets. Then again, if you’re a Duke, why not be a Pirate as well?  Like James the Duke of Ashbrook from Eloisa James’ The Ugly Duchess. You get the best of both worlds, the dangerous excitement of a Pirate and the financial security of a fabulously wealthy Duke.

Dukes and Pirates most likely to keep me in danger and diamonds:

Whether you’re stuck on the high seas or relaxing in your chaise lounge at the country estate, a Lady likes a nice manly form to gaze upon. We want our eyes to linger on his fine assets and to make every Lady and maybe a few Gentleman to turn green with envy once they realise he is ours.

One Pirate guaranteed to get people sighing with longing is James Mallory from Gentle Rogue by Johanna Lindsay. This charismatic and dashing pirate is bound to get a bodies heart pounding. Then again  Lisa Kleypas’ hero from Devil in WinterSebastian St Vincent, future Duke of Kingston ,has a wicked charm and golden good looks that has turned many a Lady’s head.

Dukes and Pirates most likely to make me anticipate the wedding night:

It’s a hard decision, but after my analysis I have decided that I am ready and waiting for my handsome, rich and brawny Duke to pick me up on his white horse. Together we’ll gallop off into the sunset on our way to his luxurious abode to live happily ever after in affluent bliss. It seemed like the wise choice to make after having reviewed all my reading, the Dukes of historical romance are rich, handsome and possess a wicked charm and a dangerous edge that I can’t seem to resist.

Then again, maybe I just haven’t met the right Pirate. Because I definitely love the idea of a dashing rogue who goes on adventures on the high seas, with his loyal (and uncommonly hygienic) crew. It sounds like it could be a lot of fun. So, if anyone has any Pirates they think I should read please let me know your recommendations.

Here are a few more Pirates and Duke that I adore, but couldn’t quite fit into my categories above!

What’s your verdict? Dukes or Pirates?

Under the Covers is graciously giving away
all five books as pictured here (one is a March ARC)

Week-long giveaway – International

spacer

spacer

 ♡ Don’t want to miss any of our posts? ♡ 

Follow me

Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
32 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Andra

I voted for dukes. I don’t think I’m cut out for sea travel and adventure on the high seas.

Timitra

Love Dukes but had to go with pirates

denise

Why not a pirate born to a dukedom?! Best of both worlds.

Amy R

I prefer dry land so it was Duke for me.

Elizabeth

I agree with denise…a pirate duke

Kathy Valentine

I love both,but I lean alittle more towards the pirate’s side!!! I love the whole high sea’s vibe!!! Awesome article suzanne,loved it!! Shared on all my socials!!

Monique D

Read Katherine Bone’s pirates, then we’ll talk! Great article!

Glenda

I do remember Danielle Harmon having some sexy Pirates in her books.

Kim Perry

Devil in Winter is probably my favorite historical!! I love St. Vincent!

Cynthia N

I’ll take one Duke please.

Laurajj

Oh I had to vote for Dukes….but oh so close!!! Pirates are great too!

Anita H.

Since I’m not one for any adventures on the high seas, I’m definitely picking the Dukes!

Sue G.

I like both, but would prefer a Duke! The clothes I’d get to wear would be wear more prettier!

Ruth

Like me a duke but pirate Mickey O’Connor from Scandalous Desires will always have my heart.

Irma

Elizabeth Hoyt’s Maiden Lane wins in my case.

Joanna M

I’m a germophobe so clean-shaven, ruffle-wearing, sweat-free, bergamot-and-musk smelling Dukes is my main dish! =D

Andra

I voted for dukes. I don’t think I’m cut out for sea travel and adventure on the high seas.

Monique D

Read Katherine Bone’s pirates, then we’ll talk! Great article!

Timitra

Love Dukes but had to go with pirates

Glenda

I do remember Danielle Harmon having some sexy Pirates in her books.

Kathy Valentine

I love both,but I lean alittle more towards the pirate’s side!!! I love the whole high sea’s vibe!!! Awesome article suzanne,loved it!! Shared on all my socials!!

denise

Why not a pirate born to a dukedom?! Best of both worlds.

Amy R

I prefer dry land so it was Duke for me.

Elizabeth

I agree with denise…a pirate duke

Laurajj

Oh I had to vote for Dukes….but oh so close!!! Pirates are great too!

Anita H.

Since I’m not one for any adventures on the high seas, I’m definitely picking the Dukes!

Kim Perry

Devil in Winter is probably my favorite historical!! I love St. Vincent!

Irma

Elizabeth Hoyt’s Maiden Lane wins in my case.

Cynthia N

I’ll take one Duke please.

Sue G.

I like both, but would prefer a Duke! The clothes I’d get to wear would be wear more prettier!

Joanna M

I’m a germophobe so clean-shaven, ruffle-wearing, sweat-free, bergamot-and-musk smelling Dukes is my main dish! =D

Ruth

Like me a duke but pirate Mickey O’Connor from Scandalous Desires will always have my heart.