Review: The Sea of Tranquility by Katja Millay

Posted September 25, 2015 by Francesca in Reviews / 3 Comments

Review: The Sea of Tranquility by Katja Millay
The Sea of Tranquility
by Katja Millay

4 Stars


Released: November 13th 2012
Published by Atria Books
Narrator: Candace Thaxton, Kirby Heyborne
Length: 13 hrs and 10 mins
Pages: 426
Format: Audiobook

“I recommend this for fans of HOPELESS by Colleen Hoover and TEN TINY BREATHS by K.A. Tucker.”
~ Under the Covers

This is one of those hyped books that I’ve owned for a long time.  A couple of years ago everyone was raving about it and it sort of got pushed back on my to read pile enough that it got lost and forgotten.  Now it was finally its turn and I’m just a little ….. underwhelmed.

I think this has a lot to do with changes in reading taste for me, and things that I’ve already read before and now I’m over.  Had I picked this up when it came out it was fresh, new and interesting.  This is a young adult contemporary story about two people that are extremely broken and damaged and how they help each other heal and move forward.

I recommend this for fans of HOPELESS by Colleen Hoover and TEN TINY BREATHS by K.A. Tucker.  It draws on the same angst and emotions as those books did for me.  Even though this story didn’t quite hit me like those did.  I think I would’ve liked to see both of them grow up a bit more and have them meet a few years later, that would’ve been perfect.

Josh Bennett has suffered loss.  Losing his mom to a car accident at an early age devastated him and his father, and now he finds himself in high school and all alone, without a family.  He’s learned to cope with the pity of others around him but he hates it.  He’s learned that he’s bound to lose everyone he cares for and keeps himself isolated from most people.  Until the new girl starts coming around and forcing her company on him.

Nastya doesn’t speak.  By choice.  After tragedy struck her and her life dramatically changed.  Josh’s company and the ease of their non-speaking relationship starts to draw her out of her shell.  I loved the strength and pace of their bond and connection, and that build up in the book was my favorite part.  They slowly break through each others barriers until they complement each other so well.

There were some things that just didn’t hit the mark for me.  One of those being Nastya’s actions towards Josh at certain point in the story.  It didn’t make sense to me especially once my suspicions of what happened to her proved wrong.  It made me a little angry and question why everyone was so on her side when he was the one that was done wrong.  Of course, then his actions pissed me off and I just wanted to throttle both of them!  But I digress.  When the big reveal of her past and confrontation with her demons comes, I found it…. anticlimactic.  Yes, this book was already somber but I wanted to dig deeper and go darker here.  After such trauma and devastation in her life, I wanted more closure for her.

Josh and Nastya have gone through a lot in their lives and they’ve matured maybe more than someone else their age, but they are still immature kids stumbling through big life traumas.  And I think ultimately that’s what I didn’t connect with as much as I wanted in this story and why the rating isn’t higher.  The writing in this book was superb though, and I found myself sighing and swooning at how deep some of the lines were.  And maybe rolling my eyes at how cheesy others were.  That’s the appeal of these books, I guess.  But in the end it was an enjoyable read and I’m glad I took the plunge and experienced it.

“I can be your other hand when you need it.”



*This video was not made by us!  But love the quotes she used in it.


About Katja Millay

Katja Millay graduated with a degree in film and television production from New York University’s Tisch School of the Arts and has worked as a television producer and film studies & screenwriting teacher. Her debut novel The Sea of Tranquility was a recipient of the American Library Association’s Alex Award and was named one of the Best Books of 2013 by the School Library Journal. She currently resides in Florida with her family.


What did you think of our review?
Let us know your thoughts in the comment box below!


 ♡ Don’t want to miss any of our posts? ♡ 
Follow Under the Covers: Facebook | Twitter | Tsu | GoodReads | Email 

Follow me


Blogger/Reviewer at Under the Covers Book Blog
I’m a 30 something sun lover living in the Big Apple (read New York).I’m a book and coffee addict and lover of all things elephants.

I get easily distracted by pictures of sexy guys and have tons of book boyfriends.I keep all my alpha males chained to my basement and guard them fiercely.*Back off bitches*I like to see Jason Momoa as a lot of those boyfriends, because ….. mmmmmmm JASON.MOMOA!

I’m a part time graphic designer (yes, everything you see on UTC has been done by me), run my husband's business from home and on a good day I’m a self appointed superwoman (she who can do it all).I love blogging with my girls and I couldn’t do it any other way!My first love is everything paranormal, but in the past few years I’ve re-learned to love contemporary romance.Every once in a while I like to mix things up with a historical romance, a steampunk or an LGBT book.Because I need variety to avoid book slumps.I don’t always need an HEA although I prefer one, and I love authors that can rip my heart out and make me ugly cry.
Follow me

Related Posts

Tags: , , , , , , , ,


Under the Covers Book Blog Comment Policy
Please read our comment policy here.

Leave a Reply

3 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
Amy RElizabethTimitra Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Notify of

Thanks for the review Francesca


their relationship development sounds good but i don’t like reading books where the decisions of characters doesn’t make sense or when characters don’t grow….thank you

Amy R
Amy R

Thanks for the review, this sounds good.