I received this book for free from Publisher in exchange for an honest review.
This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
ARC Review: Thief of Shadows by Elizabeth Hoyt
Thief of Shadows

5 Stars

Book Info

Released: June 26, 2012
Series: Maiden Lane #4
Pages: 360
Format: ARC

I wondered how Elizabeth Hoyt would top the fascinating and well-written pirate hero, Mickey of the last book. However, it was obvious from the very beginning that Hoyt had a plan for Winter Makepeace. One that worked so well that it may have become my favorite book of the series.

As the headmaster of the home for foundling children, Winter is stoic, but caring. I wasn’t sure how I would handle his story because he has never quite been a favorite of mine. That has changed after reading this book. As the sun sets and the skies darken, another side of Winter appears. At night, Winter is the Ghost of St. Giles, the protector of the streets and the boogeyman of criminals. In the fourth book of the series, Hoyt delivers yet another story that reigns you right in. With her eloquent and descriptive writing , a spit-fire heroine and fascinating hero, THIEF OF SHADOWS is sure to be a hands down winner for loyal readers and new fans alike.

I was literally blown away with the romance in this one. Hoyt develops their relationship slowly, adding that mysterious allure that really drew me in. The book starts off strong, giving us readers a taste of the dark side where the Ghost does what he is meant to do. I loved this side of Winter because it added mystery, danger and a sexiness to the story that wasn’t in his character previously. Hoyt created a magnificent hero in Winter Makepeace, making him one of my new favorites in historical romance.

Now, there was the hard task of finding someone suitable for Winter and I think Hoyt did a great job of balancing him with Lady Isabel Beckinhall. She was fun and smart, the perfect complement to Winter. Their interactions with one another displayed both their palpable chemistry and each other’s personalities well:

“Where am I?”
He kept his voice to a low, barely audible rasp. Perhaps if he whispered, she wouldn’t recognize him. “My home.” She cocked her head.”I won’t touch your mask if you don’t want me to.”
He watched her, calculating. He was naked, in a strange house, and wounded. The odds were not in his favor.
She raised one elegant eyebrow. “If you’d let go of my wrist?”
He opened his hand. “Your pardon.”
She rubbed her wrist, her eyes lowered demurely.
“I saved your life earlier, and you’re quite at my mercy now” – her eyes flicked over his nude body- “yet I don’t think you truly ask my pardon.”
She raised his gaze to his, intelligent, humorous, and utterly seductive.
The danger was palpable.
Winter’s lip twitched. “Perhaps I’m just a rude fellow.”
“Rude, undoubtedly.” She flicked a finger over the small bit of material covering his pelvis, and his base flesh stirred in mindless respond. “But ungrateful as well?”
He raised his eyebrows. “I trust you do not blame me, madam, for my present state of undress. I do vow, I woke thus and know not who to blame but you.”
Her eyes widened just a fraction and she bit her lip as if to quell a tremor of laughter. “I assure you my, uh, curiosity was prompted merely by a desire to find out there you were wounded, sir.”
“Then I am honored by your curiosity.

With heart and heat rolled into one, THIEF OF SHADOWS is a definite must-read for historical romance fans! Hoyt really has outdone herself…yet again.

Favorite Quote:

“I would do violence for one glimpse of your naked breasts. Bleed for one taste of your nipple on my tongue.”


Click on the covers to buy the books




About Elizabeth Hoyt

Elizabeth Hoyt is the New York Times bestselling author of over seventeen lush historical romances including the Maiden Lane series. Publishers Weekly has called her writing "mesmerizing." She also pens deliciously fun contemporary romances under the name Julia Harper. Elizabeth lives in Minneapolis, Minnesota, with three untrained dogs, a garden in constant need of weeding, and the long-suffering Mr. Hoyt.


What did you think of our review?
Let us know your thoughts in the comment box below!


 ♡ Don’t want to miss any of our posts? ♡ 
Follow Under the Covers: Facebook | Twitter | Tsu | GoodReads | Email

Follow me

Similar Posts

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Really great review Ann I definitely want to read Thief Of Shadows and the rest of this series!!!


Yay! I’m glad someone else saw what I did in Thief of Shadows. I’m torn between Scandalous Desires and this one. I really can’t pick my favorite!

Breath of Life Reviews



Great post. Love this series and I am looking forward to reading this next one. Such great books.

Thanks for the chance.

Under the Covers

Thanks Timitra, I think you’ll find it hard to choose between Mickey (hero of the book previous to this one) and Winter! Both are so awesome!

Ahh Adria! I’m so glad I’m not the only one who thinks this!

Hey pamerd, thanks so much for checking out our site. Hope you see you here again!


Maria D.

Great review! I’ve been reading this series and it just gets better and better with each book

Under the Covers

Yes Maria! I totally agree, I feel like Hoyt is unstoppable right now!


[…] Noble | GoodReads | Our Review Thief of Shadows: Amazon | Barnes & Noble | GoodReads | Our Review Lord of Darkness: Amazon | Barnes & Noble | GoodReads | Our Review Duke of […]